Literature review matrix template for prisma 20 inclusion exclusion criteria matrix
Use this literature review matrix template for prisma 20 inclusion exclusion criteria matrix to streamline your systematic review. It helps you document decisions transparently and meet strict doctoral standards. Save time by organizing your screening process with a clear, structured framework.
Decoding PRISMA 2020 Terminology
1) Identify 'screening' as the initial title/abstract review phase. 2) Understand 'eligibility' as the full-text assessment stage. 3) Define 'exclusion reasons' as specific, coded justifications for removing studies. 4) Note that 'PRISMA 2020' requires a flow diagram showing numbers at each step. 5) Ensure your matrix columns align with these phases to avoid rubric penalties for missing data points.
Fixing the Spreadsheet Setup
1) Create a new Excel sheet with columns for Author, Year, Title, and Abstract. 2) Add a 'Decision' column with dropdowns for 'Include' or 'Exclude'. 3) Insert a 'Reason' column linked to a predefined list of exclusion codes. 4) Use conditional formatting to highlight excluded rows for quick visual checks. 5) Save the file as a template to reuse for future reviews, ensuring consistent data entry and reducing manual errors during the screening process.
Managing Plagiarism and AI Concerns
1) Write exclusion reasons in your own words to avoid high similarity scores. 2) Cite the original studies correctly in your matrix notes. 3) Use the template as a structural aid, not a content generator. 4) Review your final document with a plagiarism checker before submission. 5) Document your decision-making process in a separate log to demonstrate original analytical work and satisfy academic integrity requirements.
Using the Ready-Made Frame
1) Copy the provided table structure into your project file. 2) Populate the first ten rows with your initial search results. 3) Apply the inclusion criteria strictly to filter relevant studies. 4) Record the specific reason for each exclusion in the designated column. 5) Update the flow diagram counts as you progress through the screening phases. 6) Finalize the matrix before writing the narrative section to ensure data consistency and save significant time on the final draft.
| Rubric criterion | What the professor wants | Where students lose points |
|---|---|---|
| Clarity of criteria | Specific, measurable rules | Vague or subjective language |
| Consistency | Uniform application across all studies | Inconsistent decision-making |
| Documentation | Clear record of every decision | Missing exclusion reasons |
| PRISMA alignment | Correct flow diagram numbers | Mismatched counts in the diagram |
Can I use this template for qualitative reviews?
Yes, the matrix structure works for qualitative systematic reviews. Adjust the inclusion criteria to focus on study design and theoretical framework rather than statistical outcomes. Keep the exclusion reasons specific to qualitative methodology standards.
How many studies should I screen initially?
Start with all results from your database search. The matrix helps you manage large volumes by filtering out irrelevant titles and abstracts early. Aim to reduce the list to manageable full-text assessments within two weeks.
Is it okay to share my matrix with a co-author?
Yes, sharing the matrix ensures consistency in decision-making. Use a shared cloud document to track changes and resolve disagreements. This collaborative approach strengthens the validity of your systematic review process.
Have a different question? Ask it here → — the bot answers with a full step-by-step guide.